Meanwhile Signal Android stopped working on my #Jolla. I can receive messages, I just can't send them. Yay.

There is Whisperfish for #SailfishOS:
github.com/aebruno/whisperfish

...but the last release is from April, and it has the very same problem. -_-;

And moxie cannot be bothered to standardize the protocol, because "the ecosystem is moving". FML.

Follow

@rysiek Hypothesis: It's about control.

The reason Signal isn't federated, is because Moxie wants to be able to change the protocol at any time. He famously blogged as much.

Rapid client/protocol changes would also become effectively unmanageable if they had multiple binary desktop apps shipped through various channels not directly under their control.

When federation becomes a realistic option, client diversity probably will as well.

ยท Web ยท 1 ยท 1 ยท 4

@HerraBRE oh, that much is entirely clear to me. Thing is: federation will *never* become a realistic option, because moxie does not want that.

Signal would benefit from having unofficial clients, and one way of doing that would be versioning the protocol and saying: "hey we will support that version for X months". That would at least give client developers a timeframe to shoot for!

As it stands, it "you can't have the cookie and can't eat it either". No native clients, and no help for devs.

@rysiek No disagreement. Just venturing the hypothesis that it's the same underlying reason.

Because everything you just said would apply to federation as well.

Sign in to participate in the conversation
Mastodon

Generalistic and moderated instance. All opinions are welcome, but hate speeches are prohibited. Users who don't respect rules will be silenced or suspended, depending on the violation severity.